Free, a radical story turning disruptive (2/3)

Previous: Free, a radical story turning disruptive (1/3): Going Radical

carte-sim-free-mobile www.clubic.comTackling disruption

In 2009, Xavier Niel, Free founder and owner, has made up his mind: the future of Internet will be mobile. Therefore, Free invests m€ 240 for a mobile license that will make Free the fourth mobile operator in France and changes its fate.

How will Free replicate the big hit of the Freebox, associating a dramatic advance in technology (ADSL), with an emblematic product (Freebox) and an unchallenged pricing (€29,9) in the mature mobile market?

When push came to shove, Xavier Niel found the magic formula, adopting a ‘Less is More’ approach and questioning generally accepted ideas:

  • Operators subsdidize mobile handsets (against long-term commitments), and please customers wish to change regularly their device? Free will shape ‘Sim-only’ offerings, handset being acquired separately by the customer. Free message could be translated as: ‘Your real concern is now about unlimited calls and bill control, you don’t need running until exhaustion after latest shiny expensive phone’; it makes all the more sense in an equipped market where Smart Phones penetration tickles a 50%;
  • Mobile consumptions are diversified, leading to a large range of rates and complex fee schedule? Free will propose a straighforward range made of 2 monthly susbcriptions: €2 for 2 hours of calls and unlimited SMS, €19,9 for unlimited calls, SMS, MMS and mobile Internet (3 Go data cap);
  • Customers want to manipulate mobile handest in retail stores? Free will commercialize his service exclusively online, thus confining cost structure;
  • Customers are used to a perfect quality of network? Free start will be somewhat hesitant on network capacity, hand-over with the partner network, and coverage.

Xavier Niel

What could have been a terrible bet resulted in a fantastic market entry:

  • Free Mobile has attracted 870 000 subscribers in Q1 2013, far ahead of competition: SFR + 29 000 customers, Bouygues : + 20 000 customers, Orange :   -361 000 (+ 85 000 subscribers but lot of prepaid users) (2012 comparative analysis here);
  • Consequently, Free subscriber base surged to 11,5 millions: 6,1 millions mobile subscribers, a figure higher than the 5,4 millions broadband subscribers;
  • Q1 2013 tunover is m€ 907:  m€ 295 for Mobile and m€ 615,6 broadband;
  • Iliad’s market capitalisation has risen more than tenfold since 2004 to €10bn;
  • Last but not least considering legacy, Free is N°1 in customer satisfaction for the fourth quarter in a row (TestnTrust).

Let’s replay  the scene:

  • A product worse from a traditional standpoint, but performing better in areas such as price?
  • A first come to market which tends to be crappy but matching deeply social expectations, shifting value, and thriving a new market, through a combination of ‘low-cost’ and ‘Sim-only’ attributes?

Free Mobile clearly offers the ingredients of the disruptive recipe. Additional viewpoints show how Free inevitablbly moved from radical to disruptive innovation:

  • Free adopted a classic ‘Low cost – High value’ approach that would cherish Christophe Midler : differentiation and lower costs are achieved simultaneously; it could be part of next ‘Blue Ocean’ case studies, as Free stresses a selection of features of the value proposition, while reducing or eliminating services that are less valued.
  • According to Benoit Sarrazin, ‘Free Mobile’s strategy is not only about discounts; it’s a prime example of disruptive innovation, combining a change in the prevailing mental schema in the sector, identifying unfulfilled latent customers needs, communicating via a community of enthusiasts, and optimising cost structures’;
  • Free does not only differentiate: it resonates with one of the deepest social crisis France has known, where millions of people under poverty theshold could not access mobile service otherwise. I prefer ‘Happy Ending’, so call me naive, but I like to believe Xavier Niel is sincere when he declares: ‘My greatest point of pride is that last year we gave the French €2bn in purchasing power. Each French person, I gave €40 through my work’.

Free not a pigeon

Free roadmap

Free is not the type of firm able to stand still. What could be the coming marks on its roadmap?

  • From the outset, Free is regularly upgrading its Freebox Revolution, and a new Freebox is  on tracks for 2014, to keep ahead of  Telco competition: Orange just released its Live Box Play, quickly adopted by 300 000 subscribers;
  • Think out of the Freebox? Telco boxes are challenged by new entrants offering Internet streaming-boxes (OTT-Over The Top) such as Apple TV, Google TV, Roku, Boxee, Amazon, and ‘Smart TV’ sets; has a time come for Free to think of another form of box, ‘a Box in the Cloud’? Deutsche Telekom and others like Swedish operator Magine and Motorola are experimenting Cloud TV, ‘shifting all functionalities of the set-top box into the cloud’, ‘bringing live TV and cloud PVR, removing the complicated installation of set-top boxes, dishes and cables’;

  • Free is concurrently working on reinventing its distribution model;
  • Is Free thinking of going abroad? ‘Telecoms is a national business. There isn’t a European market’ answers Xavier Niel;

  • What about extending its share in the value chain, going for content acquisition and production, set-up studios for original production as as Amazon and Netflix did recently? Free position has always been focused on being the best platform for multimedia distribution, not producing content;

  • Going more on software and shaping a kind of ‘Free Operating System’ like Google did with Android? Free is much more focused than Google which juggles many things, sparkling innovation in multiple directions: it likes to play on a limited number of creative projects at a time, and control optimized sofware and harware integration… just like Apple;

think outside the box

Free is probably not going so far away:  it shrewdly bought itself LTE license for next-mobile generation (€m 271 for 4G 2,6 GHz, though no position in the 800 MHz frequency band), and it’s going to hit the mobile nail, according to its telco DNA.

What will be Free next shot? Stay tuned for our next episode on the Free story.

Next: Free, a radical story turning disruptive (2/3): Roads to ‘Free’ dom


7 responses to “Free, a radical story turning disruptive (2/3)

  1. Hello Nicolas,
    Thanks you for your post. As indicated in you post, one of Free’s most insightful move was to understand that many consumers didn’t need a perfect quality network.

    My sister switched from SFR to Free several years ago, when Free came out with their 19,99 Euros unlimited calls offer on cell phones. One thing she said was that she didn’t need to have comprehensive network coverage, all across France, largely because she spends most of her time in Paris. Therefore, she preferred to pay a smaller price with less coverage. And that’s part of the reason why she switched to Free (the other reason being that Free offered unlimited calls).

    This is a classic example of disruptive innovation. Leading companies, as Christensen shows in The Innovator’s Dilemma, tend to “overshoot” market demands. In other words, performance offered by leading companies tends, in time, to exceed what the market wants. This, in turn, creates a vacuum at the bottom of the market, in lower market tiers, opening the way for a low end disruptive innovation.

    This has happened in many industries, whether its disk drives, healthcare and, you have convincingly showed that it has happened in the mobile industry, as well.

    Guillaume Villon de Benveniste

  2. Pingback: Qu'est-ce que l'innovation de rupture?

  3. Hi Nicolas,
    Great post !
    One remark or open question about the distribution model: Free has opened some physical shops called “Free Center” just before launching their activities: don’t you think this aimed at enabling some of their customers to touch the devices?

    • Sure, you’re right; at the launch of Free Mobile, you could not find a Free store to manipulate your future handset like in an App store: but things are here to change, and Free is assumed to test new kind of retail store!

  4. Pingback: Quelles sont les ruptures dans le marché des télécoms et de l’IT d'ici 2020 ?

  5. Pingback: Qu'est-ce que l'innovation de rupture?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s